Trade Hightower for Mendenhall?....WHIR

[danielgreen091]

12 team standard scoring. 1 keeper, NON-PPR, we start QB,RB,RB,WR,WR,WR/RB,TE,DEF,K.

Chris Wells owner has said that he is willing to give me Mendenhall for Hightower straight up. Is this a good trade for me?

My Roster

QB
Phillip Rivers
Brett Favre

RB
Ronnie Brown
Frank Gore
Reggie Bush
Tim Hightower
Shonne Green
Bernard Scott
James Davis

WR
Marques Colston
Braylon Edwards
Santonio Holmes
Eddie Royal

TE
Jeremy Shockey
Dustin Keller

DEF
San Diego

K
N/A

[robnestrick]

If this is a dynasty league, I'd say yes. Hightower will eventually be phased out by Wells, but Mendenhall, although not impressive so far, will phase out FWP. In a redraft I stay still...


Help me out...
viewtopic.php?t=441567

[mtlenway]

I would stand pat as you are right now. As things stand Hightower is the starter but will likely lose the roll to Wells when health thereby falling to the back up roll, but with Wells history of injury he should get a fair share of carries. As for Mendy he is strictly a back up at this point to WP.


viewtopic.php?t=441577

[danielgreen091]

Anyone else?