To Grab Steve Smith (NYG) - Drop S.Hill or Mcgahee? WHIR

[sigriffey]

I want to gamble on Steve Smith (NYG) to become a favorite target of Eli Manning. WHo do I drop: Shaun Hill or Willis McGahee? Or someone else?

12 Team H2H non-keeper
My Roster:

QB-Phillip Rivers
QB-Matt Ryan
WR-Anquan Boldin
WR-Anthony Gonzalez
WR-Ginn Jr.
WR-Harvin
RB-M.Jones-Drew
RB-M.Lynch
TE-T.Gonzalez
K-Folk
DE-Philadelphia

Bench: Mark Clayton, Willis McGahee, Shaun Hill, Earl Bennett

[sabomnim]

IMO id drop hill

[inthecards]

I think McGahee - not because Hill is that great but he might end up giving you some trade bait when some starter goes down. McGahee is going to be lucky to be the 3rd best back in B'More. If Hill doesn't pan out you can drop him during pickups once the season starts.

Good luck this season.

[shaba]

I actually like S. Hill this year. I think he is real undervalued as back up QB. Although Mcgahee will be taking a back seat to Ray Rice, i think you have more depth @ WR then RB, so personallly I'd drop Mark Clayton. He never does much every year. And if you are going to grab any Giants WR i'd take HIxon over Smith if he's available. Good luck

[marley972]

i agree with the guy about dropping Mark Clayton....but I'm big on Steve Smith this year too...i still remember his days at USC and he was a super stud...he just hasn't had time to break into the NFL yet because of Plaxico....i'm taking Smith today at my draft