Which is better? WHIR

[steelyoface]

Team A

Brees, Favre
D. McFadden, P. Thomas, A. Bradshaw, G. Coffee
A. Johnson, D. Jackson, E. Royal, E. Bennett, L. Robinson
O. Daniels
M. Crosby
Giants

OR

Team B

P. Manning, Favre
D. McFadden, R. Rice, A. Bradshaw, G. Coffee
A. Johnson, TJ. Houshmanzadeh, E. Royal, E. Bennett, L. Robinson
O. Daniels
M. Crosby
Giants


Only a three player difference....thoughts? WHIR

[jvh4jvh4]

I like Team A. I like Brees and Thomas Better than Manning or Rice even though T.J is better than Jackson.

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=441811

[robnestrick]

I like B better...

Help me out..
viewtopic.php?t=441815

[default01]

Team A. Completely agree with jvh4jvh4.

Brees > Manning
Thomas > Rice
DJax < Housh

The upgrade of Housh isn't enough to overcome the other downgrades.

[Mello]

Team A. Completely agree with jvh4jvh4.

Brees > Manning
Thomas > Rice
DJax < Housh

The upgrade of Housh isn't enough to overcome the other downgrades.

I agree with this exactly. Specifically, I think the drop off between Thomas and Rice will be more than the gain from Jackson to Housh.

[H00KemH02NS]

Depends on the scoring. Seriously, that's huge in the difference between Brees/Manning and TJ/DeSean...

[bounce]

I like A.

Help me please? viewtopic.php?t=441865

[FFBKING]

I like A but just slightly. I think Brees is better than Manning. At WR I like Housh more than Desean, but not significantly (kinda colder on both then most), but I like Royal better than both of them. I hear Seattle will run alot and although Jackson has talent, Philly always spreads the ball around. If Rice takes the full load in BAL, he could be better than Pierre, but I'm not convinced that happens. Pierre is hurt currently and isn't supposed to return till the season begins. Plus they like Mike "Tinker" Bell for some reason. Also Bush is in the mix till he gets hurt. That being said Pierre impressed me last year and I think he is a sure bet for goalline carries and the bulk of the regular carries, although bush should get most of the catches.

[LowGear]

Tough call ... I do prefer team A more as I'm a huge Brees fan.

[Wiserman20]

I think you're splitting hairs on this one.. if both teams are scenarios you're living with you're good either way imo..

Peyton vs. Brees... I don't have a crystal ball to say who outscores who but I think we can all agree they are Elite.. Elite is Elite...

D Jax vs. Housh - Both are top recievers on their respective teams, both have above average QB's.. again coin toss on that one.

Pierre Thomas vs. Rice - Before recently I would have said I like the consistency of Thomas being the guy, however now he's banged up, not playing the rest of the preseason, and COULD potentially lose goal line carries.. Rice is still a relative unknown as well based on how much play time he gets.. Again could be splitting hairs on that one.. if Bell ends up not getting the goal line carries from Thomas, I like that aspect over Rice ( Rice has a vulture ).

viewtopic.php?t=441923