Trade Proposal WHIR

[Gmazz06]

10 Man .5 PPR (Standard ESPN Scoring)

TEAM 1 (My Team)

QB: Donovan McNabb
RB: Clinton Portis
RB: Derrick Ward
RB/WR: Santana Moss
WR: Larry Fitzgerald
WR: Randy Moss
TE: Antonio Gates
K: Jason Elam
DEF: Eagles
BENCH:
Knowshon Moreno
Earnest Graham
Jerricho Cotchery
Bears
Eli Manning
John Carlson
Chester Taylor

TEAM 2

J. Cutler
L. Tomlinson
D. Williams
J. Addai
A. Boldin
A. Gonzalez
T. Gonzalez
Chargers
M. Crosby
L. Evans
J. Jones
K. Walter
T. Edwards
T.J. Duckett
J. Maclin
N. Washington

I havent offered this trade but i think he will bite. I wanted to know what everyone thinks. Can I get more from him?
TEAM 1:
C. Portis (or D. Ward)
L. Fitzgerald
TEAM 2:
L. Tomlinson (or maybe D. Williams)
A. Boldin
K. Walter

Anyone think he will go for it?

[Gmazz06]

bump

[Goody]

If it was me, I wouldn't! LT is being drafted ahead of Fitz in many leagues and I think Boldin may be the best WR on ARI. He had better numbers than Fitz last year in the games he played and Fitz got most of his TDs while Boldin was out. Warner targets Boldin more than Fitz.

Personally:

LT > Portis

Boldin = Fitz

Walter makes this even more non enticing.

It doesn't hurt to offer it, but I don't think he will bite if he knows what he is doing.

Good luck!

[Gmazz06]

I think you might have misread the post. I have fitz and portis. So does that mean you think i should offer?

[PWillis52]

He read it fine, he means if he was the other guy he wouldn't think of accepting it. You should offer it in his opinion but don't ask him to include Walter. Make it LT and Boldin for Fitz and Portis, that's what Goody was saying.