Trade advice Barber for White and Mcfaden

[jacobcal81]

my team
QB McNabb, sanchez
RB P thomas, Mcfadden,J Jones, Lesean McCoy, Moreno, Donald Brown
WR Fitzgerald, A johnson, White, Hixon, Morgan
TE Schancoe
K Akers
DEf Redskins
I had the last pick in the draft and took white knowing I could trade him for a back, but now i wonder if I should go with my team as is and see if one of RBs steps up then i got offered Hines ward and barber for thomas and white I don't like that trade so i am going to offer White and Mcfadden for Barber should i do this trade

[billsfan05]

I personally dont like this offer. Baber will be splitting carries, and even though he is a beast i think your giving up to much. IMO i think McFadden will have a better year and will end up with RB 1 type numbers. 20 or more carries plus he can catch out of the back field (if PPR). White will still get you 9-12 td this year. I think barber will get you the same but i really like mcfaddens upside.

[bungle613]

Bad offer, you need a much better upgrade if you are dealing DMac and White. I just told another guy not to deal DMac and Boldin for POrtis and 2 mid tier WR. Aim for top 10 RB for White and DMac.

[WhipperSnappers44]

I personally wouldn't make this trade.....Roddy is a Top WR (as in top 10) and DMC is going to breakout this year and be a nice RB. MBIII will split alot of carries this year with F.Jones and I don't like this offer at all for you!

If anything, try and combo up any of (J.Jones, McCoy-possibly to the Westy owner, Moreno, D.Brown-possibly to the Addai owner) with a WR (Hixon, Morgan, possibly White but I wouldn't).....and trade them for a decent RB.

Your WR's are tight right now and your RB's are servicable (DMC, Pierre)....so keep your WR's and do some packaging to get a great RB and/or a better backup QB and a better Def. (don't like Wash Def)

BTW.....your trading Hot Rod also depends on how many RB's and WR's do you start? Do you have a Flex position? Also, please include the league settings.....is it PPR, etc....(just helps determine an approach)

Definately do not make the trade though!

WhipperSnappers44!!!