big trade, need advice

[bbalevic23]

I was sent the following trade and its very close. Id love to get your thoughts on it.

I give: Pierre Thomas, Beanie Wells and Bernard Berrian

I get: Matt Forte, Wes Welker and Corell Buckhalter


While I do already have Moss, I would trade welker to another owner who loves him. Welker is trade value here and I wouldnt start him and Moss at the same time......well.....maybe against really east teams, but thats it.


Its a 10 team yahoo h2h league redraft. Non PPR
All tds are 6 points. 40 yards per point passing and 20 yards per point rushing and receiving.


QB Tom Brady
WR Randy Moss
WR Kevin Walter
RB Pierre Thomas
RB Kevin Smith
TE John Carlson
W/R Steve Slaton
BN Beanie Wells
BN Jonathan Stewart
BN Bernard Berrian
BN Donald Brown
BN Ahmad Bradshaw
BN LeSean McCoy
BN Edgerrin James
BN James Davis
K John Carney
DEF Tennessee

[TruNinerFan]

I would make this trade in a heart beat. You are getting a potential top 3 Rb, who is not involved in a RBBC, catches the football and gets goal line carries. You are giving up a guy that has a sprained MCL and will be splitting carries and an unproven rookie. Plus, I love the upgrade from Berrian to Welker.