Which is a fair trade? WHIR

[robnestrick]

In a dynasty, no ppr.

Team A: RBs - Jacobs, Portis, Steven Jackson, J.Lewi
QBs - Cutler, Big Ben
Picks - 1.3, 1.10, 2.2, 3.3, 3.10

Team B: RBs - P.Thomas, W.Paker, F.Jones, A.Bradshaw
QBs - Brady, McNabb, Schaub
Picks - 1.5, 2.5, 3.5

Which trade is fairest?

1. Portis/Betts/Big Ben for Schaub, F.Jones, 1.5 (probably gone will be Moreno, Wells, D.Brown, and McCoy)

2. Portis/Betts/Big Ben, 1.10 for Schaub, F.Jones, 1.5

3. Portis/Betts/Big Ben for Schaub and 1.5

4. Your own trade

[MAXIMIS]

#2 IMO.
Thanks for your help on mine

[whodey77]

I'd go with #2 as well

please help
viewtopic.php?t=442189

[Picksburgh]

thank you for helping me, but i honestly have no idea

[Crapjacket]

#2 I think. But I would offer #3 to open negotiations.

[robnestrick]

1. Portis/Betts/Big Ben, 1.10 for Schaub, F.Jones, 1.5

2. Portis/Betts/Big Ben for Schaub, F. Jones and 2.5

With the age of Portis in a dynasty league, do you think option 1 or option 2 is more realistic?

[itsyourboyl]

In a dynasty, no ppr.

Team A: RBs - Jacobs, Portis, Steven Jackson, J.Lewi
QBs - Cutler, Big Ben
Picks - 1.3, 1.10, 2.2, 3.3, 3.10

Team B: RBs - P.Thomas, W.Paker, F.Jones, A.Bradshaw
QBs - Brady, McNabb, Schaub
Picks - 1.5, 2.5, 3.5

Which trade is fairest?

1. Portis/Betts/Big Ben for Schaub, F.Jones, 1.5 (probably gone will be Moreno, Wells, D.Brown, and McCoy)

2. Portis/Betts/Big Ben, 1.10 for Schaub, F.Jones, 1.5

3. Portis/Betts/Big Ben for Schaub and 1.5

4. Your own trade

sorry cant help here i don't know how to do dynasty don't want to give bad advice

[eric31216]

fairest is #2 i think, but depending on which side you are i would tweak it to get max value

[spyder0314]

2 is the fairest, thanks