Chance To Get AP in a Dynasty

[tmoney26]

12 team league start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1k, 2dl, 3lb, 2db. standard scoring no ppr

my team

qb-rodgers, flacco, stafford
rb- d.williams, r.brown, k.moreno, j.norwood, r.williams, c.buckhalter
wr-a.johnson, roy.williams, v.jackson, c.henry, e.bennett, s.rice, j.iglesias
te- o.daniels, celek, v.davis
k- folk
dl- j.smith, w.smith, d.tapp
lb- d.ryans, k.morrison, l.woodley, a.curry, r.mauluga
db- a.wilson, e.coleman

the offer

i give
a.rodgers, d.williams, r.brown, r.williams

i get
d.mcnabb, AP, kevin smith

Should I take this offer?

[floppyX]

How long are the players signed for?

[tmoney26]

You can keep players up to a maximum of 3 years plus one additional year if you franchise the player.

We are allowed to keep an entire starting lineup plus one offensive and defensive rookie

[floppyX]

It's not a landslide win for you. You'd be pretty questionable at RB for a while. AP/Moreno looks great for the future, but not so great right now. Rodgers is a freaking stud and is a better fantasy player at this point than McNabb. I'd prolly pass if I were you.

[tmoney26]

Good point. actually all the players on my end outscored the other comparable players

[Picksburgh]

It's not a landslide win for you. You'd be pretty questionable at RB for a while. AP/Moreno looks great for the future, but not so great right now. Rodgers is a freaking stud and is a better fantasy player at this point than McNabb. I'd prolly pass if I were you.

Rodgers is definitely over McNabb in FF right now, but AP/KSmith isn't a terrible starting lineup until Moreno takes over Denver.. Might be a wash this year compared to Dwill/R.Brown, but your future will look bright. Just something to think about. Ksmith had almost 1000yrds last year(rookie year) on a 0-16 team

[tmoney26]

Ok I rejected the first offer and I received another offer.

I give
a.rodgers, r.brown, r.williams, v.jackson, b.celek

I get
d.mcnabb, a.peterson, t.ginn

This guy is pretty hard up for rodgers and I think this is a decent offer. Should I take it? It does make my wr's a little weaker but I'm liking what I'm seeing so far out of c.henry in the preseason and this isn't a ppr league. Also, we get points for kr/pr td's so that bumps ginn up a bit. What do you think?

[tmoney26]

Need some help here.

[cspirk]

I'd counter with a better WR or include a TE depending on who is on his team and take the deal. I think McNabb will have a solid season (although Rodgers holds more value in the long run obviously)... but you're not even giving up a stud RB to get ADP..... I'd probably do the offer he just sent you but seeing that he's persistent, I'd counter with a slight upgrade for you.

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=442859

[TruNinerFan]

I would take the counter offer. Rodgers is a stud, but Mcnabb is no slouch. You are getting AP, that is worth the downgrade at QB. I love the fact that you are getting rid of Ronnie Brown, that is one guy that is over rated every year.