Which WR would you drop? Smith or Heyward? WHIR

[converge241]

NYG Steve Smith
Darrius Heyward Bay


Im higher on Smith personally but looking for opinions

14 team deep keeper league

Thx

[RWLongy4]

I haven't heard encouraging things from the NYG about smith. I think Heyward-bey has more upside.

[bulll911]

With Plaxicco out, Smith has a great opportunity to shine this year, may be worth seeing how he does.

[Houser33]

With Plaxicco out, Smith has a great opportunity to shine this year, may be worth seeing how he does.

I agree. I think the Schilens-Higgins combo will get more looks than DHB. That and Eli>>>Russel.

[soty]

Not too much offensively to get excited about in OAK this year. Bey may surprise, but I would go with Smith. As already mentioned Burress is gone so someone has to step up. I like the upside of Smith > Bey this year. Good luck!

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=442333

[Bronco_7]

Go with Smith and see what happens. I would not take anyone outside maybe McFadden from the Raiders.

Thanks for the help on mine.

[sublimeandy]

drop heyward bey. he might have more upside, but it probably won't be until 2011. plus jemarcus russel is throwing him the ball.

[TruNinerFan]

I would drop DHB

[Houser33]

Here's a question. WHo are you other WR's? How many keepers?

Its the age old problem of trying to win now vs. locking down the future.

Now: Smith>>DHB
2 years from now: DHB>>>>Smith

If you can afford to stash DHB on your bench, I'd keep him. However if you plan on using Smith this year (and maybe next year), then I think you have no choice but to drop DHB even with his potential.