Matt Schaub for Eli Manning and Crabtree

[Newkie]

I was offered this trade for my Schaub, is this something worth doing?
I am in a PPR H2H 10 player league. Below is my team, and feel fit to give me advice on who could go and who could stay based on what you see.
There are a couple of WR's still out there that might be worth picking up instead of worrying about Crabtree.
Branch, Burelson, Kevin Curtis, Robiskie, Sydney Rice, Hakeem Nicks, Joey Galloway, Michael Clayton etc.

Carson Palmer
Matt Schaub
MJD
Marion the Barbarion
Roy Williams
Reggine Wayne
Ocho Stinko
Hines Ward
Braylon Edwards
Jeremy Shockey

Beanie Wells (should get alot of playing time equal to Hightower?)
Leon Washington (Lots of receptions?)
Donald Brown (is he worth keeping around?) he backs up Addai
Fred Jackson (he is starting for Lynch while he is out)
Glen Coffee (is he worth keeping around seeing he is a backup?)

Thanks in advance

[phi261]

I wouldn't do it. Schaub is poised for a breakout season. Crabtree is coming off a big injury and is not signed yet and is a rookie. Pass it up.

Help me out: viewtopic.php?t=441538

[TruNinerFan]

Don't do it. This trade is bascially Schaub for Eli straight up because Crabtree will be a non factor this year.

[iky]

Sounds like a bad deal. I wouldnt even mess with Crabtree, Nicks is a way better option than him and you would not gain anything by swapping Schaubb for Eli. Dont do it x3

[Script-Ohio]

Hell no. Schaub + Palmer is an awesome platoon combo, all the upside of platooning them vs weak defenses + insurance in case one of them goes down. I was targeting that combo myself but ending up grabbing Brady in the 2nd instead. Crabtree is a waste of space, undraftable in a 10 team league.