SJax,Royal for Calvin,RBrown

[gmoney973]

I give Steven Jackson and Eddie Royal
I get Calvin Johnson and Ronnie Brown

10 team redraft 0.5 RB PPR, 1.0 WR PPR

QB Matt Schaub
WR Roddy White
WR Eddie Royal
RB DeAngelo Williams
RB Steven Jackson
WR/RB Kevin Smith
TE John Carlson
K Gould
DEF Houston
Bn Anthony Gonzalez
Bn LeSean McCoy
Bn Bernard Berrian
Bn Earl Bennett
Bn Bernard Scott
Bn Kellen Winslow

[WhipperSnappers44]

Hmmmmm...this one is pretty tough but I think I would stay put!

I think the value of a "healthy" SJAX is far more greater over Ronnie then the difference between CJ and Royal!

Sure.....Royal doesn't have a QB worth a darn but neither does CJ and CJ is able to get it done. Royal got it done last year and with or without Marshall I think Royal has a nice season again this year!

So.....I wouldn't make the trade....just stay where your at now!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[Script-Ohio]

I say no. SJax to Ronnie is a considerable downgrade with PPR, and Calvin to Royal isn't quite as much of a downgrade as you might think with PPR IMO. Your team is solid, I wouldn't mess with it without a really nice offer.

[Gmazz06]

Agreed this trade will leave you to shallow at RB. If you feel comfortable with 900 yards and 8 tds/45 rec as your RB2 than id pull the trigger! Calvin(1.0) > S Jax(0.5)

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=442297

[mattdelight]

the upgrade at WR doesn't justify the downgrade at RB. STAY PUT. And Eddie is gonna be $$$ this year in any PPR league. Marshall's situation just makes Eddie's value soar.

Your team is lookin' too good right now.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=442456

[RBManiac]

do this deal. Steven Jackson will go nowhere this year, that o line is horrible, along with the QB and his crappy injury poblems, they traded holt away, and they have an injury prone Avery...all that said...all eyes on Jax. he gets stopped at the line everytime, plus they will be playing teams that will air it out alot, and st louis wont have time to be running it alot.

Ronnie Brown has no competition at RB. He is an absolute monster when he is healthy.

take the trade...ronnie brown is an upgrade and sois MegaTron..despite what the hype says.

fine..fine..lets say ronnie isnt that good...he will still produce the same as Jax will..leaving you a huge upgrade on WR.

[gmoney973]

the dilemma i have is that i am in 2 money leagues and in both leagues I have Steven Jackson and DeAngelo Williams as my top 2 RB,