Rivers/D.Will/Carlson for Brees/Slaton/Clark. WHIR!

[mattdelight]

Yahoo! H2H 10 team league .5 PPR all TDs = 6 points

was just offered Drew Brees, Slaton, and Dallas Clark for Phillip Rivers, DeAngelo Williams, and John Carlson.

Worth the downgrade at RB for the upgrade at QB in a passing TD = 6 point league?

As always, WHIR.

[RWLongy4]

I like that a lot for you, thats only a small step down at RB wheras you get a nice upgrade at QB and TE.

[waswik]

i would take the deal, slaton was solid last year and will continue to be productive this season. d.will cannot keep up what he did last season IMO. brees is a huge upgrade at QB. You are basically giving up your first and third round pick for their first and second.

[baseketball4life]

i would do it

clark way over carlson

brees over rivers


dwill and slaton gonna be close

[mattdelight]

Interesting take. Would you still do it if you knew my roster is the next question.

QB: Rodgers, Rivers, Big Ben
RB: D.Will, Gore, F. Jackson, L. White, D. Ward, A. Bradshaw
WR: W. Welker, V. Jackson, D. Driver, D. Hester, S. Breaston

Only reason I have 3 QBs is because I drafted Rivers in the 7th round since everyone was waiting so long to get a QB so I saw great trade value there. Big Ben was dropped by another team and I picked him up solely as a replacement for Rodgers' Week 5 Bye when Pitt plays Detroit.