by bazzy_51 » Mon Aug 31, 2009 5:38 pm
why would you repost this in a totally different topic?? need to chill out a bit and maybe try helping others to get answers on yours...
as for the deal, no you get killed in it...
Westy/McCoy>>>>>Ward/Brown - no one has ANY idea what the hell is going to go on in Tampa, there are 3 RB and talks are Ward will get 2 series, then Graham will get the next 2, then Caddy gets the next 1, then they start it all over again, so if its a lower scoring game Ward could easily only see what 4-6 series a game?? yeah thats a huge decrease in value from a top 5 RB in the league. McCoy even with you having Westy carries more value then Brown does also.
Williams/Harvin>Driver/Gates - the side your giving up wins this because of 2 simple reasons, you already have 2 very capable TEs so why do you need to add another when you know damn good and well you won't get adequate value for Carlson or Miller. Second driver is 100% second fiddle to Jennings, and with other emerging weapons in the GB receiving corps Driver's value decreases even more to the tune that 1000 yards and 4-5 TDs would almost be a stretch for him now. add to it the fact that you have no idea how Harvin will fare in Minny, he could end up turning into a very good WR3 low end WR2 for you. and Roy Williams IS the WR1 in Dallas and with TO out of the picture will be looked to early and often by Romo...
you lose in all aspects of this deal IMO, it hurts the overall value of your squad more then it helps, you go from having 1 top 5 RB, a potentially top 10-15 WR, if McCoy gets opps could be a top 20 RB by seasons end for what? a top 3 TE, lucky to be a top 20 RB in Ward, a top 30RB and Driver who will be lucky to be a top 20-25 WR... not a chance i do that deal your roster is PERFECTLY fine as is...
A big thanks to deluxe_247 for the sweet sig!
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
