Does this trade help me?

[Birderdude]

In an 8 team league. We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1flex,1K,1D.

My roster: QB: Rogers, Warner, Farve
RB: Slayton, MBIII, P. Thomas, LenDale, Rice
WR: Roddy White, Boldin, Welker, Housh, Roy Williams
TE: Gonzo
K: Gostkowski
D: Ravens

The trade proposed to me was:
I give: Warner, P. Thomas, Boldin
I get: Hasselbeck, Gore, DeSean Jackson

His roster is: QB: Hasselbeck, Garrad
RB: LT2, Gore, Sjax, Felix Jones
WR: DeSean Jackson, Calvin Johnson, Royal, Avery
TE: Olsen, Carlson
K: Rackers
D: Titan, Redskins

Would Gore be enough of an improvement at RB to justify giving up depth at QB and WR? What would be a good couter offer?

[Watts123]

Honestly I like you team just the way it is. getting Gore is a small upgrade at RB, but I am very high on Pierre Thomas being a solid player so I would stand pat.

[RWLongy4]

No, that's far too much to give up for a small step up at RB and big step down at WR/QB.

[Birderdude]

What if I countered with this:

I give him: Rogers, P. Thomas, and Welker
for: LT2, Hasselbeck, Jackson

[dblj9911]

Yes, you win on this trade. Your back up qb is only going to be playing on Rodgers bye week and between Favre and Hass you should have one decent match up between the two. I think that Gore is a big upgrade at rb compared to Thomas. I would try and keep Bouldin and throw in TJ or Roy. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?t=442845

[hammertoes]

I would stand pat. Your team as it stands right now doesn't really have any weak spots. Don't try to fix what ain't broke.

Thanks for help with mine.