Am I giving up too much for Felix and Royal? WHIR!

[cspirk]

12-team DYNASTY league...

I'd receive:
Jones, Felix DAL RB
Berrian, Bernard MIN WR
Royal, Eddie DEN WR

I give up:
Ward, Derrick TBB RB
Gonzalez, Anthony IND WR
Williams, Roy DAL WR

Would you make this trade??? Felix would be my 3rd RB and I wouldn't have to play him (remember, dynasty format as well), but I'm losing a little at WR? Leave a link to questions and I will help you!

Here's my lineup (QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1 RB/WR, TE)
QB: Rivers* Edwards Quinn
RB: Chris Johnson* Kevin Smith* Ward, J. Charles
WR: Andre Johnson* Roy Williams* A. Gonzalez* Henry, M. Austin, L. Moore, L. Sweed
TE: D. Keller* V. Davis

[cspirk]

Please help... the offer is currently on the table. WHIR

[Sex Panther]

That's a tough call.

I don't see Felix ever being a load back and you have 2 young, talented, and relatively proven guys in CJ4.24 & Smith - so I gues you have to ask yourself - do you think Felix is a better long term commodity than those 2?

Dealing Roy Williams could also really blow up on you - he's young enough and on a team talented enough to emerge as a legit lead WR - I'm not sold it's going to happen, but I'd be naive to think it's out of the realm of possibility.

I also like Gonzalez to emerge as a legit threat as the 2nd WR in the Indy offense.

I think I would pass on this deal.

[ScarletKnight]

I wouldn't do it. Individually, I would take each of the three players you are giving up over each of the three players you would be receiving. Ward over Felix just because Ward is the main guy in TB and Felix plays behind Barber. Roy Williams over Eddie Royal because I don't trust Orton and I see Brandon Marshall staying on the Broncos. Finally, I'd even take Anthony Gonzalez over Berrian even though some think that with Favre, Berrian's value has increased. After watching the Vikings against the Titans on Monday, granted it was preseason and Berrian was out, I don't think the Vikings are gonna be any more of a passing team than they were last year.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=442860

[JaysFan]

I wouldn't do it.

Gonzalez>Royal
Ward=Jones
R. Williams=Berrian

Help with mine??? viewtopic.php?t=442905