RB or WR In Rd 1? (I'll Help U As Always)

[Lucky7]

10 team redraft with 2 keepers, standard scoring, no ppr.
I have the 6th pick.
I kept CJ424 (7th round keeper) and Royal (13th round keeper).
Who do I pick with the 6th pick in the first round?

With the various players being kept, I think I will have the the following choices:
1. Pick Gore or Westbrook in round 1 and someone like Calvin/Wayne/Jennings in round 2. OR
2. Pick RMoss in Round 1 and someone like Brown/KSmith in round 2.

What combo looks better?
1. Gore/Westbrook+CJ424+Calvin/Wayne+Royal OR
2. Brown+CJ424+RMoss+Royal.

Leave a link.

[MAXIMIS]

I'm thinking Gore over Moss. If you can get Megatron that's no small step down but Brown would be IMO compared to Gore

Help? Thanks in advance: viewtopic.php?t=442930

[Lucky7]

any other thoughts?

[bazzy_51]

If you know you could get Gore 1st round and Megatron 2nd round i would grab that in a heatbeat over Moss/Smith. I like the first option alot better then the 2nd option, but are you sure you can get Megatron in the 2nd round? If not then i say for Moss/Smith because going from Gore/Calvin to Gore/Wayne is a huge drop and a big drop even compared to Smith/Moss... you have to be sure you can get Calvin 2nd round otherwise take the safe route and go with Moss first round and Smith second round.

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=443032

[Lucky7]

If you know you could get Gore 1st round and Megatron 2nd round i would grab that in a heatbeat over Moss/Smith. I like the first option alot better then the 2nd option, but are you sure you can get Megatron in the 2nd round? If not then i say for Moss/Smith because going from Gore/Calvin to Gore/Wayne is a huge drop and a big drop even compared to Smith/Moss... you have to be sure you can get Calvin 2nd round otherwise take the safe route and go with Moss first round and Smith second round.

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=443032

I'm not sure about getting Calvin in 2d. I dont see any WRs going before my 6th pick. Here's who picks 7,8,9, and 10 have kept:

#7: kept Hightower and MRyan (could go RB/WR in rounds 1-2)
#8: kept MTurner and PThomas (likely will go WR/QB, maybe WR/WR)
#9: Kept ADP in 1st round (likely will go RB in 2d)
#10: Kept Rivers and A Bryant (likely go RB/RB)

Likely players available before my #6 pick in round 1:

RBs: Gore, Westy, Jacobs, Barber, Portis, Brown, KSmith
WRs: All of them

If I pick Gore, there will likely be 4 more RBs picked before I pick again (Westy, Jacobs, BArber, Portis)
AND
2-3 WRs picked (Fitz, Moss, AJ)

That leaves Calvin available.

Do I take the risk and pick Gore???

I'll answer yours now.

[tracyjesq]

That's a tough one. I like Gore/CJ over Moss/Smith definitely. So the risk you're taking is that someone will take CJ before you. If your analysis is correct, there would be no more than 3 WRs off the board before your 2nd round pick. CJ could go 3rd (in WRs) but that would still leave you with a top 4 WR. I would do Gore and take the risk you get CJ. Best of luck to you!!

Help with mine please?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=443036&p=3059257#p3059257

[bazzy_51]

That's a tough one. I like Gore/CJ over Moss/Smith definitely. So the risk you're taking is that someone will take CJ before you. If your analysis is correct, there would be no more than 3 WRs off the board before your 2nd round pick. CJ could go 3rd (in WRs) but that would still leave you with a top 4 WR. I would do Gore and take the risk you get CJ. Best of luck to you!!

Help with mine please?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=443036&p=3059257#p3059257

+1 here... i would risk the WR situation in the 2nd round. Go with Gore and if for some ungodly reason all 3 WR are gone (btw you haven't even mentioned Fitz so you still have actually 4 WR options with that 2nd pick) then your gonna get one hell of a RB Duo that you could trade away after the draft for some WR help. I say go with Gore and take one of the top 4 WR left out of (and i list them the way I, and i say how I would draft them) CJ, AJ, Moss, Fitz. good luck to you!

[fierro33]

if i knew for sure u would get calvin then i would say go ahead and take gore. In a non ppr guys like moss and calvin stand out alot more. I prob wouldnt chance it because if these guys are any good calvin would be gone before you get a chance to get him.... therefore i would grab this years top wr by far in a non ppr league randy moss.....brady and moss will put up monster numbers this year. Moss could easily get 18 tds. i do love ronnie brown this year i think ricky is done.....but i also love kevin smith. I dont think gore stands out too much over them.......i would take moss and then KS or RB.....its hard to pass up kevin smith but damn brown i really think he will be a top back this year

[fierro33]

heres my link

viewtopic.php?t=443051

[Lucky7]

Just finished the draft and ended up with Gore and Moss (chose Moss over Calvin).

QB: McNabb (Edwards)
RB: Gore, CJ424 (J Stew, McCoy, Coffee)
WR: RMoss, AGonzalez (Royal, LMoore, CHenry)
Flex: Ronnie Brown
TE: Gates
K: Akers

Thanks for the help