My Marshall/roethlisberger for Warner?

[JOBA]

This is my counter offer. I was originally offered Warner and Kevin Smith for LT and Marshall. Which, if either, do you like more? Also, we can keep up to 3 players at the end of the year, so if i add Smith, it makes my team much younger for the future, although hopefully DMAC takes care of that.


My Squad:

Qb: Palmer
RB:LT
RB: CJ4.24
WR:Welker
WR:Ward
WR:Marshall
TE:Clark
K:Crosby
DEF:SD



B:Roethlesberger
B:McFadden
B:McCoy
B:Santana Moss
B:Breaston

[mgold7]

I doubt the other owner will take that trade. You're last offer was much better, but I don't see either of them as fair.

[JOBA]

I was offered the first 2-for-2, then i asked about the 2-1, and he told me to send it. I think i could have either one accepted, but your opinion is the 2nd (warner for marshall/roethlisberger) is the best by far?

[bazzy_51]

out of the 2 the 2-1 is the better deal, i just don't know how much i like it. Your squad is already pretty thin at WR so ridding of Marshall will mean you will have to start one of Moss or Breaston as your WR3 which isn't too bad, but given Ward is your WR2 i think it still leaves you thin at WR. I definitely wouldn't take the 1st deal tho. i say stand pat for right now as Palmer may be a big surprise this year, and if he goes down yes Ben isn't too sexy as a fantasy QB but he could get the job done.

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=443032

[mgold7]

If you can get Marshall/Roethlisberger for Warner to go through, and you really want Warner, do it.

I don't know why you're after Warner though.... I hope you don't expect him to perform like he did last year, as I would have to say that's unlikely...
Marshall's value may also be higher than you expect, because if he gets traded to a team like the Jets, then his value skyrockets...

If you want a #1 QB, you may want to trade for Rodgers or Brees. I also like McNabb a lot this year too, he could have a great year. Palmer could surprise you as well, but it's ultimately up to you though..
Good luck