NEED HELP ON TRADE must do by tomorrow

[jp05ser]

Hey everyone ready for football??? i def am. hope you guys can help me out. Im weak as RB (ill include my roster below) but i got a interesting trade offer. here it is.

I give him: Big Ben, Thomas Jones, and Brylon Edwards

I get: Peyton Manning, Leon Washington, and Reggie Bush OR Kevin Smith (my choice)

Peyton wont help me a ton since i have Rodgers already but let me know what you think ASAP please he wants to know by tomorrow

QB- Aaron Rodgers
RB Brandon Jacobs
RB Thomas Jones
RB/WR Braylon Edwards
WR Andre Johnson
WR Reggie Wayne
TE Dallas Clark
D- Ravens
K Ryan Longwell

Bench

Jonathan Stewart
Donald Driver
Ahmad Bradshaw
Tend Ginn Jr
Visanthe Shiancoe
Ben Roethlisberger
Jake Delhomme
Jeremy Shockey
Michael Bush
Mark Clayton
Edgerrin James

[jp05ser]

because of Bush being hurt a lot and Thomas being there to take away touches. I was leaning towards doing the deal with Kevin Smith instead. if i do the deal. what do you guys think?

[wyld stallions]

I would do this in a heartbeat. Manning>>>>>Big Ben, Washington >Jones, KSmith >Bush>Edwards.

Highway robbery

[jp05ser]

but heres my thing i already have Rodgers so manning isnt a big upgrade... washington will never play unless someone gets hurt i dont ugh im so torn

[Skins4Ever]

I give him: Big Ben, Thomas Jones, and Brylon Edwards

I get: Peyton Manning, Leon Washington, and Reggie Bush OR Kevin Smith (my choice)

Peyton wont help me a ton since i have Rodgers already but let me know what you think ASAP please he wants to know by tomorrow

but heres my thing i already have Rodgers so manning isnt a big upgrade... washington will never play unless someone gets hurt i dont ugh im so torn

So essentially you're getting Kevin Smith, lol.

[jp05ser]

well do you think he would go for me giving him Thomas Jones..Donald Driver and Big Ben for Matt Forte?

[jp05ser]

or instead of driver give him Edwards

[Skins4Ever]

well do you think he would go for me giving him Thomas Jones..Donald Driver and Big Ben for Matt Forte?

It is impossible for me to speculate what he would do, pitch him your package and see what happens.

[2ksports]

this is a no brainer. You can turn around and trade one of your QBs for an upgrade elsewhere.

[FFBKING]

Do the trade for Forte now. Both trades are good (definitely Kevin Smith in the other trade), but I agree that Peyton isn't a huge upgrade over Rodgers. The benefit to the other trade is that you would have the ability to trade Rodgers or Manning for another RB though. So it depends on if you want another RB2 in a trade for Manning (Ronnie Brown to pair with Kevin Smith) or you want a top 3-4 guy in Forte. Either way, Kevin is an upgrade from Thomas Jones, and Forte is also a huge upgrade.