A.Bradshaw vs R.Mendenhall....

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

in a standard H2H league which backup RB would you rather have on your roster

R.Mendenhall
or
Ahmad Bradshaw

[Tayma]

If i had Jacobs or Parker i would like them both as handcuffs...If neither of the them was injured i would take bradshaw. Personally if i didnt have Parker i dont think i would draft Mendenhall by him self. But i would definitely draft Bradshaw because he will get more playing time then Mendehall. And according to nfl.com "8-10 Rushes for 60 Yards on a regular basis" sounds decent and his value only gets higher if he is injured...

So in general they're both pretty good handcuffs. Parker is more likely to get injured imo, so take that as you may.

See Mine
/viewtopic.php?f=44&t=443101

[Earl Van Dorn]

"Fast Willie" Parker is more likely to break down than Jacobs so I would take Mendenhall.

EVD

[spberg82]

Depends who gets hurt first, Jacobs or Parker. Whoever goes first, the back-up will win the touches.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=443136&p=3059720#p3059720

[MotorCityKitties]

I'd rather have Bradshaw. Derrick Ward was quite productive as the #2 guy in NY last season and we have no idea how the carries will shake out. They both need an injury to become fully productive, but NY has shown that their #2 back can have value without an injury.