Ricky Williams VS. LeSean Mccoy

[Moose484848]

Who's going to be more valuable overall this year???

I say RICKY!

I know all the hype is with Mccoy but i really think Ricky is a hidden gem. The fins will use him a lot in the wildcat regardless of Ronnie. They just signed him to a 2 year extension, they say he looks great in camp...

What do you all think?

[Carnac]

Need to see your roster.

You are talking about risk/reward value. Blind....if you have a solid RB core, go with McCoy. If you are thin stick with Ricky. It all depends on Westy's ability to stay healthy.

good luck

link viewtopic.php?t=443243

[Moose484848]

Thanks,,

I'm very VERY thin at rb. We play 2 rbs, but you can play a 3rd at the Flex (RB/WR)

I have Lendel White, Felix Jones, Donald Brown, Ahmad Bradshaw, Ricky Williams

Was wondering if I should trade Ricky for Mccoy. Leaning toward sticking to Ricky bc I think its a safer bet...

I don't have Westbrook...

Now what you think?????

[bobsmith65]

I would gamble with McCoy. More upside in my opinion. I would put him in the same boat as Donald Brown. Could pay off nicely if you're patient.

With Ricky Williams..I think you know what you're getting from him,

[UNDEFEATED]

The gamble isn't with mccoy. McCoy is highly talented in a great situation.

Ricky is ricky. Most if not all of his skills have eroded greatly. Dont buy into his extension. He looks weak in camp. Making the extension odd.