Who wins with this trade

[houstonherdfan]

standard yahoo + 1 ppr

Deangelo Williams and Witten

for

L. Fitzgerald and S. Slayton

[beavis69]

It's a tough one...
Based on what Houston is saying, Chris Brown will be the goal line RB. So Slaton may not get that many TDs... Not sure how long can Warner go... I'm leaning towards D. Williams/Witten side to be better..

Help me!
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=443421

[eaglesfan]

WIthout seeing your team...I'd rather have Williams an Witten.

[cwhitty]

I'd also rather have Whitten and Williams. I like Fitzgerald a lot but if you look at the numbers with Boldin around they aren't as spectacular. Slaton is a good back but if you're not going to get the TD that's a tough pill to swallow. The only reason Carolina drafted Stewart is because they never really gave Williams a chance to shine. Last year he had had enough of that and dominated. Stewart or no Stewart the guy is a beast.

[Skins4Ever]

I would rather have Williams and Witten in this scenario as well.

[WhipperSnappers44]

Not sure what your needs are (TE or WR) but either way I think the D.Williams/Witten side is better

Slaton is great and all but will lose TD's to Brown and Fitz is awesome but I agree with another poster in that when Boldin plays Fitz still get's receptions and yards but no TD's as Boldin gets those (and quite a few Receptions and Yards himself)

D.Williams is great and with Stewart banged up then he will run a full load and Witten=best TE in the game!

Good luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[houstonherdfan]

Thanks all. Everyone in this particular league wants D. Williams and/or Witten. wittencause 6 of the 8 are Dallas fans. Williams cause I got him so cheap I guess (6th round). So everyone thinks I'll give him up cheap. He is my top RB regardless of where I got him. don't often ask for everyones opinion cause I am pretty set in my ways regarding FF but have gotten some pretty interesting trade offers in this particular league. alot of it is because it is an unusual set up. They called it the 2 for league. Start 2 at all positions except Kicker + 1 flex (WR/RB). I blew off RB to get top players at other positions.

QB scoring depends alot of good completion % you get .5 per completion but lose .5 for incompletions.

Brees and Pennington my starters both sitting at 67% or better cairrer completion % and last year. Eli Manning as the back up.

Weak area WR 1 ppr

Got R. Moss, L. Moore, A. Gonzales

RB

D. Williams, K. Smith, P. Thomas, Caddilac Williams (got him last round), Cedric Benson, Jamal Lewis,

TE

Witten and Gates

K

K brown

DEF

PIT and BALT

5 bench spots interesting league.

[Vlad]

wow really ? with 1 ppr im taking Fitzgerald and Slaton and it is not even close.