Thomas or McFadden

[Supertzar85]

After tons of draft prep for my in-person draft tonight, I'm left with one question I'd love opinions on.

Pierre Thomas or Darren McFadden in ppr?

Initially I was sizzling on Thomas but now I'm drifting due to injuries and the 3 RBBC. And now after seeing McFadden in the preseason I'm developing a man-crush. Which is it guys?

Thomas pros: Dynamic offense, Bush could get hurt, strong end of the year.
Thomas Cons: Injury, RBBC/touches

McFadden pros: will get a bunch of touches, Raiders good run game, extreme talent, preseason has been awesome
McFadden cons: Raider, RBBC but lesser extent, hasn't proven it yet

Where do you guys stand?

[WhipperSnappers44]

I think I would still have to go with Pierre on this one. I also like DMC but look at the team he's on (I'm a Raider Hater) and he also has the RRBC situation with Bush and Fargas and DMC has looked strong in preseason last year and then he vanished. I think DMC will continue to be strong this year but I think Pierre (once healthy again) will be a strong contributer!

Good Luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[Supertzar85]

I agree somewhat. My gut is telling me DMC because my league is dynasty and his potential is greater. but my head is saying PT Cruiser for this year.