Trade for Aaron Rodgers

[jackattack]

I'm looking to grab Rodgers and I'm not sure if I'm trying too hard. Here's the deal I can make:

I get: Aaron Rodgers, Willis McGahee
I give: Randy Moss, LaDainian Tomlinson

Am I over-valuing Rodgers? Is the deal worth it if I get Thomas Jones instead of McGahee?

Just want some opinions. Thanks in advance.

My Roster:
QB - Matt Schaub, Matt Cassel
WR - Randy Moss, Wes Welker, Domenik Hixon, Percy Harvin, Jeremy Maclin
RB - LaDainian Tomlinson, Ryan Grant, Larry Johnson, Tim Hightower, Laurence Maroney
TE - Kellen Winslow, Brent Celek
K - Adam Vinatieri
DEF - San Diego

[Petrocelli]

Assuming standard Yahoo scoring, I'd stay put.

I think most people would pick Moss over Rodgers straight up. if you throw in LT for McGahee, I don't think the trade is fair for you.

Also, you have two decent QBs. One of the two should pan out.

[jackattack]

Forgot, yeah, standard Yahoo Scoring (for the most part). No points for completions, receptions or carries.

[bazzy_51]

thats way too much to pay for Rodgers.

Aaron will be a stud, but your talking about trading a top 4 WR and top 6-7 RB bare minimum for a potential top 5 QB and a junk RB. This is a definite no go for me.

With that being said tho you have Schaub who if healthy could potentially be a top 6-7 QB, but i would like to see a more reliable backup especially with Cassel hurt. What is available on your FA list for QBs?

[Picksburgh]

Agree with everyone else, too much

[jackattack]

Thanks for the advice. Available QBs now are: Shaun Hill, Kerry Collins, Jake Delhomme, Marc Bulger, Byron Leftwich, JaMarcus Russell, Brady Quinn, Daunte Culpepper, Derek Anderson, Michael Vick

[eaglesrock]

I would pick up Delhomme and look to trade Welker for someone so you dont have 2 Pats in ur WR corp...maybe someone like a boldin/roddy white/desean jackson

[bazzy_51]

dang ok.

Well what i would try then is one of these:

Package A: Cassel/Hightower
or
Package B: Cassel/Havrin
or
Package C: Cassel/Celek


for a QB like Hasselbeck (that would a sweet addition if the other owner goes for it), Eli, Ryan, Delhomme or Orton

i know a couple of those might be a stretch, but check the teams and whichever of those is a backup go after.

[jackattack]

Thanks again for the replies. I picked up Delhomme (FA) and dropped Cassel. Trading Welker is a good idea to save me during the bye week. I'll see what I can do.