Blockbuster Trade Proposed. Should I take it?

[Socko44]

The following trade was proposed to me in a nonppr league

I receive: Clinton Portis
Marion Barber
Brandon Marshall
Larry Johnson

I give up: Frank Gore
Kevin Smith
Terrell Owens

The rest of my team is
Tom Brady
Trent Edwards
Joseph Addai
Donald Brown
Steve Smith(Car)
Chad Ochocinco
Donald Driver
Derrick Mason
Jerricho Cotchery
Josh Morgan
Antonio Gates
Robbie Gould
New York Jets

Any help is greatly appreciated.

[WhipperSnappers44]

I would do this trade.....I think the other guy is trying to warp your mind with the good players here but I think it will work out for you. I mean Gore is a beast and they will run all day in SF and K.Smith is great and should be in for a fine year as the "Lone" back in Det and TO.....don't know what to expect from him in Buf.

On the reverse.....Portis is a top RB (has injury issues but who doesn't right?), and MBIII (F.Jones will steal some carries but MBIII is the running game in Dallas) and BMarsh (has issues and that's the only thing that scares me so....watch out with him but I seriously think by the time the season gets rolling then Marshall will want to play and will get his act together) and then LJ is a throw in (he could possible come back into form as well)!

So.....I would make this trade but Bmarsh is the scariest part of it!

Good Luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[BMadd]

Basically you are getting a free LJ in this deal. I think the other 3 vs 3 is pretty much a push. Take LJ and the RB depth.

[scoobyDoo]

I think Gore and Smith are both a decent amount better than Portis and Barber (don't like either of them much this year) but Marshall once he gets back is much much better than Owens, and you get Larry Johnson pretty much for free.

I would make the trade, and just hope Gore doesn't have a crazy good year, which is what I'm expecting out of him.

Plz help: http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=443554