MJD or Turner...WHIR

[SlayeratCP]

12 team, non ppr, 6 pts all TD's, other than that, normal points:

I have the first pick of a keeper league redraft and AP and Forte are being held. The top two guys on my board are Turner and MJD but who should I choose? I worry about MJD's injury and carrying the full workload and Turner has a tough schedule, plus Tony Gonzalez might steal some TD's. What should I do and why?

By the way I am keeping Kevin Smith and Anthony Gonzalez (losing 4th and 9th round picks)

Thanks

[lugmetric]

i'm a turner devotee, and in non PPR i like him #2 overall. sos is something that really needs less emphasis. there is a lot of turnover in the NFL every year, and what seems scary now could be a joke, and vice-versa. the guy has 500 career carries, gets the rock no matter what in the red zone, and tony g will create as many opportunities as he takes away.

i like MJD too, but i think he really has more question marks around him than turner. he's nicked already, has a new o-line, no WR to stretch the D (not counting troy williamson, sorry) and has never had a full workload. (see marion barber, 2008) i'm not saying he will be awful, but some people around here are absolutely in love.

[SlayeratCP]

Thanks for the help, I actually just made up my mind. If K. Smith is going to be my #2 back, he and MJD have the same bye week so it's easy for me. I'll go with Turner.