QB - 'C'. Lots of people love Ryan, but he didn't put up huge numbers in his rookie year. Managed the game well, led his team. But we don't care about that aspect! I'd dump Jake Delhomme. No confidence in him. Eli is really inconsistent, but I'll guess you wind up playing him more than the other two QBs.
RB - 'A'. Wow. LT. Forte. Barber. That's a heckuva trio. And then McCoy and Davis as sleepers with mega-potential. Amazing set of RBs.
WR - 'B-'. A lot of others will like your WRs better than I do. I'm not convinced in V.Jackson or Bryant -- I think they're rated higher than they'll perform, but they'll still be OK. Love DeSean Jackson. Love Chris Henry. I might trade one of your RBs to upgrade your WRs, assuming you play more WRs than RBs in your format.
TE - 'A'. I think Shiancoe will be a Top-5, maybe a Top-3 TE this year, and you probably got him late. Nice pick.
DEF - 'B+'. Green Bay seems to be adapting well to the 3-4, and they have talent on that side of the ball.
All in all, 'B+' sounds about right. Nice team.