I give this team a B+ what do you think? WHIR

[bmault]

12 man non ppr, 1 man keeper. I had the 6th pick.

1. LT
2. Barber
3. V JAX
4 Deshaun Jax
5. Forte (kept from last year)
6. Antonio Bryant
7. Matt Ryan
8. McCoy
9 Chris Henry
10 James Davis
11 Delhomme (I screwed up due to he and Ryan having the same bye)
12 Shinacoe
13 Green Bay
14 Eli

Open to any and all commentary and criticism

Leave a link!

[bmault]

Anybody?

[Analysis Paralysis]

QB - 'C'. Lots of people love Ryan, but he didn't put up huge numbers in his rookie year. Managed the game well, led his team. But we don't care about that aspect! I'd dump Jake Delhomme. No confidence in him. Eli is really inconsistent, but I'll guess you wind up playing him more than the other two QBs.

RB - 'A'. Wow. LT. Forte. Barber. That's a heckuva trio. And then McCoy and Davis as sleepers with mega-potential. Amazing set of RBs.

WR - 'B-'. A lot of others will like your WRs better than I do. I'm not convinced in V.Jackson or Bryant -- I think they're rated higher than they'll perform, but they'll still be OK. Love DeSean Jackson. Love Chris Henry. I might trade one of your RBs to upgrade your WRs, assuming you play more WRs than RBs in your format.

TE - 'A'. I think Shiancoe will be a Top-5, maybe a Top-3 TE this year, and you probably got him late. Nice pick.

DEF - 'B+'. Green Bay seems to be adapting well to the 3-4, and they have talent on that side of the ball.

All in all, 'B+' sounds about right. Nice team.

Good luck.

[TaDa]

You have 3 top 10 RBs in a 12 man non-PPR league? That's almost an automatic A. LT, MBIII and Forte are going to take you to the playoffs at the very least. I would rate your WRs at a B. Your QB situation is a tad weak, but you have 3 solid choices at QB and can play the matchups. Give that a B-. TE and Defense I would rate a B..

I definitely think that your team is playoff bound and beyond, since your RBs will put up massive numbers and all else should be gravy.

A little love please: viewtopic.php?t=443717

[dzags18]

Solid team. Forte was a great keeper and should definitely get you far. I don't think your QB situation is that bad. I think Ryan will give consistently decent numbers.

[money]

I'd give you a B right now. Maybe look to trade one of your RBs for an upgrade at QB. If you ended up getting a better QB, I'd rate your team an A-.

Please help me: viewtopic.php?t=443908

[DallasFan85]

Hey thanks for the help!

Firstly, I really like your RB core. You have some excellent trade bate and depth; personally I would try to see if you can trade Barber or LT for an upgrade at WR or even QB (I'd prefer WR for your particular roster). However, in your WR's, you have a lot of great sleepers and potential. I'm more sold on V Jackson than Bryant as a solid number 2; but I'm high on Desean Jackson this year. All reports indicate that a big year is in store for Chris Henry; so he could potentially be a nice number 2 or 3 if he picks up speed. But I would see if you would be willing to upgrade at the WR position by letting go of LT or MB3. I'm also sold on Matt Ryan at the QB position; he is someone I would draft as my starter. Behind him; it really doesn't make sense to keep 3 QB's (unless you start 2 of course), and it's a toss up between Eli and Delhomme, since both teams run the ball pretty consistently. But overall good depth and a good starter there. And I like Visanthe Shiancoe, especially with Brett Farve running the O there in Minny. Def and kicker are solid. A- man; trades or not; you should be good to go!