Eli Manning vs David Garrard

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

Which one of these guys should be my QB?

8 team H2H league with these passing settings:
TD Pass 6
Every 50 passing yards 1
40+ yard TD pass bonus 3
300-399 yard passing game 4
2pt Passing Conversion 2


Carson Palmer is my starter....so i need a good backup

[kervtrain]

I would definitely take eli as my backup. He has better options at wide receiver, and a better te in kevin boss. Plus hes in a much more productive offense.

Help!
viewtopic.php?t=444267

[reprisal]

Not sure Eli's receivers can be called better at this point. But Eli is a much better bet to actually throw some TD passes. Garrard needs a lot more yardage points to be serviceable.

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

no one thinks Garrard will eclipse the 300yd mark more than Eli?

[nolimits]

I'd take Eli as well. I really want Garrard to bust out, I just don't see it. Not that Eli is much better, but I think he's better than Garrard.

Help w/ mine? viewtopic.php?t=444401

[Knightrider29]

Garrard. He's plays for a mediocre team who will be playing from behind most games, and clearly has better passing options (Holt, MJD) than Eli does (Hixon? Smith?).

The Giants play with a run heavy offense, and will be running out the clock most nights rather than playing catch-up. Eli is surely the better quarterback, but there's no way he's going to give you the better fantasy season.