I Need your HELP!! WHIR

[mrjack81]

I just got offered peyton manning and reggie bush for LT and Donovan. Its a start 1 rb format with 1 rb/wr slot. I have Thomas jones, Leon washington, larry johnson, ryan grant and james davis as my other rbs. Plus calvin, randy moss, harvin, and berrian as my WR's. I guess the ? is if manning is enough of an upgrade in qb to make this trade. WHIR. Thanks guys, i'm pullin my hair out on this one.

[mrjack81]

i could also get felix jones or willie parker instead of bush.

[Moose484848]

wouldnt do it... manning is the only non risk guy in the deal. who knows what mcnabs value will be with vick in the picture

[WhipperSnappers44]

Thanks for the reply....

I wouldn't do this trade if I were you. I love Manning and think he is one of the greats but his time is almost coming up and he will start slowing down (age, injuries, etc...) as soon as this year (previous couple of years also).....I also thin McNabb is in the same boat so although I rank Peyton ahead of McNabb this year I think it's still only slightly!

I do however think LT will have a solid year and the predictions and favor goes well above to LT over Bush, FWP or Jones. I think anyone of those 3 are decent but they are no LT and what LT is predicted to do this year.

I would stick with LT and McNabb and you should be fine. This trade isn't worth it!

Good Luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[mrjack81]

yea but I would be gettin Manning who is a no risk and felix jones. wouldn't that be worth trading away two old risky players??

[Moose484848]

oh wait if ur getting manning i would do it....

[padrino990_200]

i wouldnt do it. the dropoff from LT to bush or jones will be alot more than from Peyton to McNabb

[cpmcda01]

i wouldnt do it. the dropoff from LT to bush or jones will be alot more than from Peyton to McNabb

I agree with this. viewtopic.php?f=18&t=444331

[Carnac]

Agree, stay put. LT will outproduce Bush>>>>>Manning over McNabb.

good luck

thanks for help with mine