Which of these RB's have the most upside?!?

[TheGhost]

Which of these three RB's have the most upside and in what order would you rank them? Thanks and WHIR!!

Fred Jackson
Carnell Williams
Edge
Willis McGahee
Tim Hightower
Jamaal Charles
Brandon Jackson
Sammy Morris
Ricky Williams

[jackie hayes]

I guess you mean which 3 out of these? Cuz I'm fairly certain that's more than 3.

I'd go Jackson > Hightower > Charles. If Jackson starts out well, he could become a big part of that offense, which should be improved with a more experienced Edwards, and TO. Hightower should get pushed aside by Wells, but he could maintain the job, particularly if Wells has injury issues. And Charles -- I guess I just don't think LJ's got much left, so while I don't see him becoming the starter, I wouldn't be surprised if he took away a decent number of snaps (making Charles more of a solid flex play than a true starting rb -- but it's something).

Caddy's kind of a wildcard, but I think there's just too much competition for carries in Tampa.

[dblj9911]

Hightower- was the goal line back last year, should be in that role again this year, and could start again when and if Wells is hurt
MacGahee- could still be the starter, but also has Rice and Maclain
Jackson- starts weeks 1-3, is the main backup with Rhodes being cut
Caddy- looked great in preseason, is a injury risk, in a crowded backfield
Williams- is Browns backup and will get his touches each week
the rest all all the same to me and will only be useful if injuries occur

viewtopic.php?t=444369