His McNabb and Portis for my Rothlesberger and Gore. Thought

[Bronco_7]

A guy has offered my Portis and McNabb for my Rothlesberger and Gore. What do you think? I really am thinking I am not gaining enough at QB to justify giving up Gore who I expect will have a monster year. My roster is below. It is not a PPR league.

Thanks in advance. WHIR

[across777]

This is a pretty even trade...on paper you'd probably improve your starting lineup. But you'd be getting two guys with some good potential (McN and Portis) but who are old and injury prone. If you are very high on Gore, then sit tight.

Personally I think Ben R and Flacco both have some upside, so even though you obviously waited on QB, you may end up ok.

good luck

[Bronco_7]

Anymore thoughts on this?

[mcace]

I'd sit tight. Portis is much lower on my list than Gore, and McNabb is going to have a rather hostile environment to play in this year... I doubt either of them lasts the season, so stay put.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=444889

[Bronco_7]

Looking for more thoughts on this one. Anyone?

[jsggggg]

Id take it i think McNabb will out do Ben by a nice margin and Portis and gore are very close. Portis was the top HB last year before he got injured he was putting up monster numbers MVP type i say take it

[WhipperSnappers44]

I would stay put.....

I consider Big Ben and McNabb almost the same (slight edge to McNabb) but both guys have issues and have an injury past.

This really comes down to Portis vs Gore and I rank Gore a few steps ahead of Portis. In PPR Gore is a beast and in non PPR he is still better than Portis who will definately break down this year.

Good Luck but I would stay put!

WhipperSnappers44!!!