Major Trade Help. WHIR

[giants71]

I was just offered offered their Randy Moss, Matt Schaub, and Balt Defense for my Marques Colston, Phillip Rivers, and TB Def.

I was also offered another version of Randy Moss, Matt Schaub, and Darren McFadden for my Marqes Colston, Phillip Rivers, and Fred Jackson

Should I accept either of these??

12 team ppr league.
It is a point per reception league. 6 pts for all tds. 25 passing yards= 1 point 10 rushing/recieving yards= 1 point. Regular defensive stats.

QB- Phillip Rivers
QB- Jake Delhomme
WR- Calvin Johnson
WR- Marques Colston
WR- Donnie Avery
RB- Matt Forte
RB- Reggie Bush
TE- Zach Miller
K- Neil Rakcers
Def- Tampa Bay

Bench:
1. RB Marshawn Lynch
2. QB Jason Campbell
3. WR Devin Hester
4. RB Fred Jackson
5. WR Nate Burlesson
6. TE Kevin Boss

[across777]

Yes, I'd do that for sure.

Colson is a good player, but Moss is still a big upgrade.

Schaub has as much potential as RIvers, but he has the injury issues. However I'd take the risk becuase getting Moss is worth it.

And Balt is a MUCH better D than TB, which sweetens the pot a little.

good luck

[Skins4Ever]

I was just offered offered their Randy Moss, Matt Schaub, and Balt Defense for my Marques Colston, Phillip Rivers, and TB Def.

I would be all over that.

[jackie hayes]

I'd take the McFadden offer. Balt d is great, but I'll almost always take a high upside runner over a good d. But they're both good offers.

It hurts to lose Rivers, but Schaub should be just as good when he's not nicked up, and Moss's upside makes this an easy deal to take.

[Dan Lambskin]

do the one with McFadden NOW!!!

[bulldog88]

Hit the accept button on #2 before he changes his mind.

[giants71]

even though it tremendously weakens my qbs?

[jackie hayes]

even though it tremendously weakens my qbs?

It doesn't. Schaub is very good, just injury-prone, and the Houston offense is very strong all over. Not what I would call "tremendously weakening" -- just a little more risky.

[bubba01]

If Schaub can stay healthy, he can put up Rivers type numbers and maybe even do better. The Houston offense will be one of the tops this year. I would for sure do the McFadden deal over the other one.

[Shotz]

Everything has already been said above. I'm just making sure you already accepted option #2. CLICK CLICK CLICK now fella!