Colston or TJ for Barber? WHIR!

[rplantz]

I get Marion Barber (and use him as an RB2 instead of McFadden) - I give either Marques or TJ.

Here's my squad for the 2009 football season. It's H2H, 12-teams, three divisions.

And I will most definitely help in return!

Thanks!

STARTERS
QB: Donovan McNabb
WR: Randy Moss
WR: Marques Colston
WR: TJ Housdmendezah
RB: Maurice Jones Drew
RB: Darren McFadden
TE: Chris Cooley
K: Nick Elam
DEF: San Diego
D: Eric Weddle (SD)

BENCH:
RB: Felix Jones
RB: Donald Brown
WR: Donnie Avery
WR: Derrick Mason
QB: Brett Favre
DEF: Jacksonville

[sheethappens]

I wouldn't make that trade. MB3 is going to share the work load in Dallas with Felix Jones and I think McFadden will be a solid option this season. I actually have McFadden within 6 points of Barber this year and having to replace Colson (BIG MISTAKE to trade him IMO) or TJ Hous with Avery/Mason from your bench is a HUGE drop off n production.

Basically this becomes Colston/TJ + McFadden vs Aery/Mason + Barber. I'll take Colston/TJ + McFadden every time and not lose a wink of sleep over it. Stand pat with your current team.

[krazyjoe8]

I know MB3 Splits with Felix but Id take him over McFadden. U got good WR depth with Avery and Mason. And ud have McFad as ur #3 RB. i Say do it...

help me plz guys - viewtopic.php?f=18&t=444917#p3068189

[across777]

First of all, if it is Colston or TJH, then make that TJH....I think Colston is a much better option who is more of a sure thing and has more upside. TJH will be ok but he's not an elite talent and he's on a new team.

But overall, I'd stand pat. Your backup WRs are not that strong and Barber has some question marks. It is not clear that Barber is better than McF, so I'd roll with what you got. Your studly WRs are going to more than make up for the lack of a good RB2, and McF very well may end up being a good RB2.

good luck

[mrjack81]

I would get rid of Housh just because I don't like hass stayin healthy all year and I REALLY dont like seneca wallace throwin to anyone. Nice trade for you though either way. Good luck. help with mine. viewtopic.php?t=445252

[snakeyez23]

i'd do tj but not colston and even then your team looks pretty solid im not sure i would do it at all