2 Trade Options help please:)

[LIGHTSOUT56]

12 Team PPR

1QB- Drew Brees,
3WR- Larry fitzgerald, lee evans, isaac bruce,
2RB- Ronnie Brown Kevin Smith, Fred Jackson, Darren Sproles
1TE- Antonio Gates
6BENCH - Matt Cassel, Steve Smith(giants), Donnie Avery, Vernon Davis, Fred Jackson, Darren Sproles
1DEF- Pittsburgh
1K- Nate Kaeding



Roddy White and Thomas Jones
for
Larry Fitzgerald and Kevin Smith/Ronnie Brown

Brandon Jacobs and Santana Moss
for
Larry Fitzgerald and Ronnie Brown/Kevin Smith

[Thunderc0ck]

I wouldn't do either of those trades man. Fitz is better than both wr's, and Brown/Smith I think are better than both rb's

[JaysFan]

I wouldn't do either.

Fitzy is the best Wr in the league and Smith and Brown are better than TJ. NO WAY on this one.

On the other deal I'd still say no because yes you get a minor upgrade with Jacobs but going from Fitzy to Moss is a huge downgrade. Your team is good you're fine and you have good RB's don't be afraid Brown is primed for a massive year.

Help with mine??? viewtopic.php?t=445454

[Picksburgh]

Boo. These trades are bad

Trade 1- You are better at WR and both RBs
Trade 2- You are better at WR and only a small drop with both RBs

[sheethappens]

Fitz is at least 40 points better than White, I have Smith and Brown both within 5 points of TJ so option 1 is a no go

Trade two looks this way, Fitz will be 60-70 points better than S Mss this year and Jacobs will only be about 30 points better than your existing RB's so that one is a no go too.

Tell him that he's trying to rip you off and you know it. Tell him he is insaulting you with those trade offers and tell him that if he REALLY wants to make a trade then it's Fitz + Bronw/Smith for White + Jacobs. THAT's fair and about even for both teams:

Fitz (130 pts) + Brown/Smith (115 pts) = 245 pts combined
White (95 pts) + Jacobs (145 pts) = 240 pts

He of course will balk at the offer but that's because he's looking to rip you off, not make an even trade. However, even though my proposal is even, I still wouldn't make the trade from your POV. With Eli now missing both Shockey and Plax to throw too teams will be even less afraid of the Ginats passing game and knowingly focus even more on stopping Jacobs. White may just be the next Edwards, great in his breakout year never to match those numbers again. Give me the one proven fantasy stud in L Fitz every time.