Caddy or Mendenhall?

[friedrich15]

who will better this year? i own mendenhall and caddy it stiing on the FA lsit should i make the move?

[latsprewell20002000]

Id say Mendenhall. I know things didnt look very good last night for him or for the Pitt running game in general but they will get it worked out. Pitt has a VERY easy schedule this season and that will help. And if FWP goes down or plays like crap then its all Mendenhall. Good luck but i would stay with Mendenhall on this one.

[Bronco_7]

I would role the dice with Caddy. Mendenhall seems to be getting lost on the bench and from accounts his play is doing nothing to get him off it. I would take Caddy and hope his knee holds up.

Please see mine

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=444777

[nesharims00]

def caddy. I picked him up myself! Mendenhalls play aint gettin him off the bench and if you watched the game, it was all FWP and then Moore on passing downs. I see caddy getting more touches since theres no way graham will consistently get those reps as long as caddy n ward are playing well. Plus caddy's got alot to play for after what hes gone through + the coaches like what they've seen from him. so instead of the 2,2,1 touches they're talkin about, I see caddy gettin anywhere from 12-15 touches and ward around 15 (including catches). GL!

[WhipperSnappers44]

I would go with Mendy here....

Caddy will be injured after weeks 1-3 and Ward is and will be the man to be the sole RB#1 on that offense in due time. If you want a guy who might get some numbers for a week or two then take Caddy but that's all you "might" get.....if you want a guy who will split carries and eventually take over when FWP goes down then take Mendy!

My choice is Mendenhall easily!!!

Good luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!