McNabb vs Schaub

[hoosier1032]

Who do I start?

McNabb @ Carolina

or

Schaub vs NY Jets

I'm leaning toward playing Schaub. He seems to be money in the bank at home. But to honest, I'm still a bit concerned about his ankle.

Would like to get some opinions from the cafe!

Thanks...WHIR

[P. Griffin]

I say go with McNabb, but it's pretty close. I wish I had this problem at QB though Good luck.

[Georgeas]

I would go with McNabb. He will be playing hard not wanting to lose his job.

[Thracken]

Michael and I actually addressed this situation specifically in the FCR podcast 4th and Goal. You should take a listen and see which way we leaned!

[hoosier1032]

It looks like people are leaning towards McNabb but I'm still torn! Anyone else?

[hoosier1032]

Bump. Anyone else?

[Voodoo]

McNabb

[sammyfan711]

I like Schaub. McNabb was such a boom or bust fantasy proposition last year and killed teams on certain weeks, too risky IMO. Schaub will at least be steady, and has a good chance to be explosive. I would play Schaub while he is healthy (ankle is fine according to his last practice report).