Hmm, pretty interesting two choices. As you know, Brandon Marshall always has the potential to make big plays. When it all comes down, I would go with Marshall for Week 1.
10 team H2H league, standard scoring [NFL.com]
QB: A. Rogers
RB: MJD, S. Jax, J. Starks, D. Murray, M. Bush
WR: M. Wallace, B. Marshall, P. Harvin, M. Colston, L. Robinson
TE: O. Daniels, J. Gresham
K: Sebastian Janikowski