QB pick up...

[dare]

I have Palmer and McNabb. (QB value is a bit more heavily weighed in our league-6pt per td)
Obviously I am concerned with their respective fragility.

I don't have much room on my bench, but if I make some, and take on a 3rd QB. Who should it be?

Kerry Collins
Byron Leftwich
Matt Cassel

[Moose484848]

I'd go with Fatty Leftwhich he looked good against the Cowboys and has a lot of weapons in the passing game. The other two qbs either dont have as many weapons nor pass as much...

Can you please help with mine??

viewtopic.php?t=446369

[dare]

bump

[dare]

bump...hurry, please, lol waivers are about to flip...I'm leaning towards Collins...

[dare]

Well Waivers passed, Leftwich is gone. Soo....
It's down to Cassell and Collins?
Anyone wanna weigh in?

[Picksburgh]

should have took lefty... If Cassel is playing this week take him, if not your stuck with Collins... Is there anyone else available?

[bazzy_51]

Id roll with Cassel... Even if he is out this week also you have Palmer who can play at least this week but Cassel will be much better then Collins over the long run this year. I really don't think that McNabb will be out tho, but thats just my opinion i don't think hes too fragile he plays through alot. Tough guy so if you must add a QB tho it would be Cassel over Collins (agreed you should have grabbed Lefty)

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=446811

[cwhitty]

Of those two it's Cassel for upside and Collins if you want to play it safe.

[Picksburgh]

i took it that you had to start 2 qbs, my mistake. You should be alright with Palmer until Donovan gets back. Depends on who you would be dropping for a 3rd QB, but I don't think I would do it.

[dare]

Depends on who you would be dropping for a 3rd QB, but I don't think I would do it.

I'd be dropping James Davis.
My Roster is below. We only start 1 QB, but we weigh them rather heavily in my league, so...
I'm leaning Cassell over Collins(who had a good report today)

____________________________________________________________
12 team, PPR, 6pt per TD for all, re-draft league:
Starters:
QB: Donovan McNabb
RB: Maurice Jones-Drew
RB: Brandon Jacobs
WR: Roddy White
WR: Donnie Avery
WR/RB: Donald Driver
TE: Visanthe Shiancoe
DST: Jets
K: Nick Folk

Bench:
QB: Carson Palmer
RB's: Chester Taylor, Fred Jackson, Laurence Maroney,
James Davis, Mike Bell
WR's: Earl Bennett
______________________________________________________
Roster: 1Qb, 2Rb, 2Wr, 1Rb/Wr flx, 1Te, 1K,1D
1PPR,
1/2pt for QB Completion, 1/4 PPrush
12 team league