TO and Addai for Grant or Slaton?

[Woodsonfan]

I have been offered a trade in my league. A dude will give me TO and Addai for either Ryan Grant, or Slaton. I have Donald Brown as my third RB. I am weak on the WR's with Larry Fitz, Braylon, Holt, and Jenkins.

I don't want to jump the gun on Slaton yet, but I also have Schaub, and I hate having too much going on the same team.

Let me know what you think!

WHIR

[preseason heroes]

I'de stick with your draftpicks. TO isn't going to have a good year, and Addai will be #2 in indy by the end of the year. Slaton screwed me over this week too, so I know how you feel. Don't give up on those 2 yet, a lot of RB's had bad week 1s (look at Turner, Forte, etc.)

Check out this trade if you have time:
viewtopic.php?t=446562

[Woodsonfan]

Thanks! I guess I want to jump the gun, but I should give my picks more time to show their worth.

[POJO_Risin]

I agree. Slaton will pan out...and Grant is a solid pick IMO.

TO is overrated right now...and Addai...well...you have Brown. I like Addai this year...but Brown is too good to sit, and you know how Indy likes to let the new guys get touches...

stay put...at least for another week...

help if you can...

viewtopic.php?t=446621

[Woodsonfan]

So after week 2, the guy still wants to make this trade...How long can I wait for Slaton to pan out? I picked up Manningham last week and he scored the most out of him, Fitzgerald, and Edwards. I still have D. Brown, R. Grant, and Slaton.

Again, should I take TO and Addai for Slaton?