Huge 8 player trade!! WHIR!!

[Mickel208]

10 Team H2H Format. 2 QB's, 2 RB's, 2 WR's, 1 RB/WR, 1 TE. PPR League!!

I give : Tony Romo, Terrell Owens, Daren McFadden, J. Gage

I get: Kyle Orton, Andre Johnson, Ray Rice, M. Sanchez


My Roster ( * Starters)
QB- T. Romo*, A. Rogers*, M. Stafford
RB- B. Westbrook*, C. Johnson*, D. McFadden, K. Moreno, L. McCoy
WR- T. Owens*, A. Gonzalez, S. Moss, P. Harvin*, E. Bennett, J. Gage
TE- G. Olsen*

His Roster
QB- D. Garrard*, J. Campbell*, K. Orton
RB - LT*, Ray Rice*, L. Washington*, R. Bush, Julius Jones
WR- A. Johnson*, W. Welker*, Ochocinco, P. Crayton
TE- J. Whitten*, D. Keller

Offensive Starters=2 QB's 2 WR's 2 RB's 1 TE 1 W/R

[POJO_Risin]

You get killed on the Orton side...

win the Andre Johnson side...but by how much is a bit unknown right now...

and perhaps wash a bit in the Rice/McFadden deal...although I think McFadden...if healthy...could bust out over Bush in Oakland.

You do need a receiver...but losing your best for Johnson probably wouldn't be the route I'd go...

Help if you can...

viewtopic.php?t=446610

[Gitterdunn08]

2QB league you are solid at that position and your counterpart is desperate for 1 solid QB much less 2!

you DO need a reciever but if you make this trade, your still going to need a reciever so it doesnt help you out to much, but you just lost a starting QB for orton.

McFadden/Rice you can argue about all day, still to early to tell who will emerge the better RB, right now they both have a high ceiling with another RB in the picture.

Would i do it? No...you dont win on this in my mind. you lose on ur QB, win on ur reviever but the points u gain wont make up for the points u lose with ur QB trade. and RB's are semi-equal at this moment in time in my opinion.

[Mickel208]

Anyone else?

[bb88]

I don't hate it actually. Rice is an upgrade over McFadden IMO and Andre is a clear upgrade over Owens. Try to see if he'll give you Garrard instead of Orton.

I actually think with Andre you'll be OK because I think Gage, Harvin and Bennett all have tremendous upside and you should be fine starting Andre and the best of those three.

I'd consider making it, but try to squeeze a bit more value out.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=446898

[organist]

I wouldn't do it.

I think that the solid production you'll get from Romo can't be made up for in this deal.

Thanks for seeing mine.

[Doughhead]

I would not do this deal. The drop from Romo to Orton is the biggest in the deal, and the fact that you lose on the QB component in a 2QB league makes it a thumbs down for me.

[Mickel208]

Added Sanchez and J. Gage to the deal. Does this change anything?

Gage will not play for me but I could use Sanchez and Orton basied on matchups.

[WhipperSnappers44]

I would say no to this trade!

You start 2 QB's and having Rodgers (elite) and Romo (elite 1st week smells elite year round) so that is a dominate in a 2 QB league. If you traded then you would be stuck with Rodgers still but have 3 mediocre QB's to go with him (Orton, Sanchez, Stafford)....I feel Orton get's his act together eventually and Sanchez/Stafford do alright but an "on Fire" Romo they won't be!

I like Rice over DMC but just barely and I like AJ over TO (but that still remains to be seen if and when AJ rebounds and if TO throws a fit to Edwards and get's thrown the ball 2 dozen times this week).....but I consider them close but absolutely put AJ in front! Then you also lose Gage who is a nice WR to have in case someone goes down or Moss doesn't keep up his week 1 STATS.

I would basically stay put just from the QB view.....in a 2 QB league Rodgers and Romo will get you far!

Good Luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[dhs3usa]

I agree with almost everyone in the 2QB league having 2 of the top 10 QB's in the league is dominant especially if it is standard scoring for Passing TD's. With Williams, Crayton, Miles, Witten & Benetter there are just too many good weapons for in Dallas for Romo not to have anything less than an above average game on a bad day.

HIR please

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=447021