Garrard or Collins? WHIR!

[mullenium]

WHich of the 2 might have a better game this week?

also Orton is available

what are your thoughts?

[Blackhawk]

I thought Collins actually looked pretty decent against Pitt. He should be a good pick up for a McNabb fill in.

Help on mine?
viewtopic.php?t=446699

[mullenium]

up

[mullenium]

anyone else?

[milostyl]

I'd say Collins.

The WR corps looks tons improved for Tennessee. I don't think anyone expected Gage to look as good as he did in Week 1. Britt was solid and now Nate Washington is expected for a full start. The one pick he threw was just an amazing grab by Polamalu. If Scaife doesn't play it could hurt a little but Crumpler is no slouch as a replacement. The running game will have more presence against the Houston D but Collins will have less pressure and have more opportunities to score TDs.

Garrard looked terrible against the Colts. The only solid play from JAX week in and week out is MJD. The Cards are much better against the pass than they looked against SF last weekend, they were using a Frank Gore focused game plan.

I'd also hold on making Orton a fantasy starter til he gets the kinks worked out in that McDaniels monstrosity Denver calls an offense. He has a good matchup but they had one last week against Cincy too and his only points came on a freak tipped ball.