Waiver pickup WR B.Edwards, Manningham, or Knox

[tmontana]

I've got the third pick in waivers
WR Candidates i'm looking at are

B. Edwards
Manningham,
Knox

I've put them in order of my current ranking of them. Any thoughts?

How would you rank them?

[THE SWAT TEAM]

Manningham NOW!!!!!!!

[thejusman1]

Ignore Manningham. It was dumb to drop Braylon Edwards. Edwards floor is probably Manningham's ceiling. The Giants are a run-first team, with Steve Smith as a clear #1, and Hixon/Nicks weren't even playing. Quinn to Braylon looked better last week, and you know the Browns will always be playing from behind and airing it out a lot.

[tmontana]

Ignore Manningham. It was dumb to drop Braylon Edwards. Edwards floor is probably Manningham's ceiling. The Giants are a run-first team, with Steve Smith as a clear #1, and Hixon/Nicks weren't even playing. Quinn to Braylon looked better last week, and you know the Browns will always be playing from behind and airing it out a lot.

I agree with you on Edwards. I was shocked last week when the owner dropped him.
What about the other 2? Would you put Manningham in front of Knox?

[tmontana]

Any other thoughts?

[timbobtoy13]

I'd go Edwards. Browns are going to be down a lot and Quinn seemed to finally look for him last week.

Giants are still a running team and will not air it out that often

Can you help me w/ this trade? viewtopic.php?t=448800

[SameSongNDance]

lol at the first response being manningham now!!!...people around here are getting higher on manningham than your everyday illicit drugs...braylon seem to be picking it up, grab him if ya can

[DukeVBall]

Unfortunately name carried more than anything. Edwards now. If Quinn keeps struggling, they'll put in DA who has better chemistry. And with Winslow gone, BE is really the only offensive weapon and CLE HAS to throw.

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=448813&p=3089751#p3089751
viewtopic.php?t=448947