Pick up - S.Smith vs M.Manningham

[TKsteve]

So im gonna pick up one of these guys...need some input.

M. Manningham NYG (WR)

or

S. Smith NYG (WR)

M . Manningham is the hot FA pickup this week, but I think in the long run S. Smith will be the more reliable fantasy WR. Let me know what you all think about this.

Thanks

[DerekR]

Gotta go with smith. He is the wr1 at new york. Manningham is still good but i think smith will produce more points

[DerekR]

Gotta go with smith. He is the wr1 at new york. Manningham is still good but i think smith will produce more points

[coltsrock]

yeah with Manningham being a rookie, i dont think he'll be as consistent as Smith

[jh2031]

yeah with Manningham being a rookie, i dont think he'll be as consistent as Smith

Manningham isn't a rookie. But, I agree that Smith is the more reliable of the two. I still think Mario Manningham will be a good WR in a deeper league. (12 teams +)

[jnmiller]

In my league both Smith and Manningham were available, and I ended up picking up Smith.

[Smoakland Hammer]

Manningham! Better after the catch. More explosive period.

[WWM]

PPR smith TD Manningham. I grabbed manningham in my TD leagues.

[jonesy37]

i don't know..i think you'll probably get the same from either, but i picked up manningham and he was HUGE last week...he seems to be setting in with Eli...i'd tend to lean towards Mario..

see mine

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=448914

[coltsrock]

yeah with Manningham being a rookie, i dont think he'll be as consistent as Smith

Manningham isn't a rookie. But, I agree that Smith is the more reliable of the two. I still think Mario Manningham will be a good WR in a deeper league. (12 teams +)

Ahh sorry, i was misinformed, but hes still a younger WR