Gotta take this right? Brady for Rivers & Manningham

[sharkbait006]

Was offered Brady and Michael Jenkins (waiver fodder) for my Phillip Rivers + Manningham
Start 1 QB, 2RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1K , 1 DEF (non-ppr, 6pt for all TDs)

My team:
QB: Philip Rivers
RB: Ryan Grant, Ray Rice, Cedric Benson, Knowshown Moreno, Donald Brown, Lendale White, Mike Bell
WR: Randy Moss, Andre Johnson, Laurent Robinson, Mario Manningham
TE: Dustin Keller
K: Tynes
DEF: Green Bay

His team:
QB: Tom Brady
RB: Steven Jackson, Joseph Addai, Tim Hightower, Michael Bush,
WR: Santonio Holmes, Lance Moore, Bernard Berrian, Chris Henry, Deion Branch, Michael Jenkins
TE: Jason Witten
K: Nick Folk
DEF: Dallas

[Bryanhoop2]

Y

(Trying to keep this short, so you won't lose any time accepting it)

[DemonDeacon]

i wouldnt

[jmalk25]

ohhh for sure i would take that!
BRADY is waay better than rivers ....and everyone is soo high on manningham.. hell slow down and you will get the better deal!

DO ITTTTT!!

help with mine
viewtopic.php?t=448807

[sharkbait006]

ne1 else?

[DemonDeacon]

ohhh for sure i would take that!
BRADY is waay better than rivers ....and everyone is soo high on manningham.. hell slow down and you will get the better deal!

DO ITTTTT!!

help with mine
viewtopic.php?t=448807

waay better as a real nfl qb or waay better as a fantasy qb? Your giving up on your number 3 wr who has huge talent. will he be a top 10 wr this year? cant say it would suprise me. Rivers should be floating right around the 30ish TD range again, and lets be honest... Brady isnt gona get 50 again, or 40... but ya 30 sounds about right. Id put Rivers and Brady at a push FANTASY wise, and wouldnt be suprised to see Rivers above Brady. Where as Manningham could end up being a top 10 player. Thats just one mans opinion.

[sharkbait006]

What if I went after Brees and offerend Rivers + Manningham for Brees ?

[padrino990_200]

definetly. i would do either but prefer brees.

[elguapoo]

I doubt you can get Brees for that but if you can of course you take that.

As for Brady, I would probably keep Rivers and Mario as you play 3WRs

[sharkbait006]

Last week this was a no-brainer. After week 2, makes things interesting. Question is.. how much better will brady be than rivers? Enough to offset the loss of Manningham whose value is questionable as well?