David Garrard for Kevin Faulk?

[CameronFree]

A guy in my league wants me to give up David Garrard (My Backup QB) for Kevin Faulk (RB)

Should I take it or counter with something different? (Be realistic)

Available QB's I could pick up to replace Garrard: Stafford, Kolb, S. Hill, Bulger, etc.

My Roster:
Peyton Manning (Ind - QB)
Larry Fitzgerald (Ari - WR)
Andre Caldwell (Cin - WR)
Thomas Jones (NYJ - RB)
Joseph Addai (Ind - RB)
Benjamin Watson (NE - TE)
Cedric Benson (Cin - RB)
Julius Jones (Sea - RB)
Lee Evans (Buf - WR)
Earl Bennett (Chi - WR)
Donald Brown (Ind - RB)
David Garrard (Jac - QB)

His Roster:
Carson Palmer (Cin - QB)
T.J. Houshmandzadeh (Sea - WR)
Braylon Edwards (Cle - WR)
Frank Gore (SF - RB)
Steven Jackson (StL - RB)
Joshua Cribbs (Cle - WR)
Felix Jones (Dal - RB)
Kevin Faulk (NE - RB)
Steve Breaston (Ari - WR)
Rashard Mendenhall (Pit - RB)
Glen Coffee (SF - RB)
Mike Sims-Walker (Jac - WR)

[dh1339]

No way.

I would want Felix or Mendenhall

[MadDog36]

I doubt you'll get either....

Try countering his trade.

If you really want another QB.

I'd go with safe - Hill and risk/reward - Stafford.

Offer him Julius Jones and David Garrard for Felix Jones and with the free spot you'd add stafford or hill, you win big.

[CameronFree]

Thanks guys. Huge help.