trade help

[Guest]

Two trades have been offered to me

Ed Mcafffery for Plaxico Burris
_________________________
duce stalley and marty booker
for
william green and mushin muhummed

my current line up is

QB B Griese, J Plumber
RB P Holmes L Smith W Green
WR T owens M muhummed D Stallworth T wilkens
TE T Gonzo M Ricks
K J Hanson Elam
D Redskins broncos

please let me know what you think

[trentvaughn]

I would do the Burress for McCaffrey trade. A solid #1 WR vs. a #2 man coming off an injury later in his career. The other trade, no way. William Green will be a stud, Muhummed is a nice #2 receiver, and Staley and Booker are both inconsistent. I know Booker had some big games last year, but there is no reason to think that him and Staley will outperform Green and Muhummed.

Trentvaughn