B Marshall Trade WHIR 100%

[zachster104]

I am thinking about offering a trade for Marshall. I need a little depth at wr and i think i can buy low on marshall right now. Who should i offer for marshall though?

Heres My Team
QB-Matt Ryan, David Gerard
RB-Chris Johnson, Slaton, Ray Rice, Pierre Thomas, Caddy, Jamal Lewis
WR-Megatron (CJ), Desean Jackson, Kenny Britt, Nate Burleson, Kelly Washington
TE- Kellen Winslow

His Team
QB-Eli, Trent Edwards
RB- D. Williams, B. Jacobs, M. Moore, K. Faulk
WR- B. Marshall, Berrian, L. moore, M. Muhammed, Jonnie lee higgins, Louis Murphy
te- shiancoe

[zachster104]

i was think maybe caddy for marshall

am i giving up too much?

[ElectricUncleSam]

Caddy is exactly what I was thinking. I think it's sell high time on Williams, and you're right, buy low on Marshall... just be cautious of what you're getting. He slipped in ADP for a reason, and it seems like everything coming out of his news and notes are negative. I'm not a Caddy believer, so if your trading partner is, you're in. Just be aware the 2009 Brandon Marshall is not and might not be the 2008 Marshall.

viewtopic.php?t=449772

[Indibuck]

i was think maybe caddy for marshall

am i giving up too much?

I like the idea of trading for a player while his value is low.

Not sure of the other owner would go for that trade though... I wouldn't.

[LBIguard]

I don't think so, I would assume you don't even play caddy, and with his knee bothering him already and reports of swelling...when is the last time he finished a season...I would say you come out ahead with a good buy low.

[GameDay_Zombies]

Caddy for Marshall is good. If he will go for it. Problem is the other manager probably spent a pretty high pick for Marshall, which may keep him from pulling the trigger. If he goes for it, make the trade.

[LaRock]

You have enough depth that if he doesn't like Caddy you could offer Thomas or Rice. That may sound like giving up too much, but I assume you start 2 RBs. That leaves Thomas or Rice as your #4 RB.

Offer Caddy, and be prepared to allow Thomas or Rice if he counters. He needs RB help and it won't hurt you to give up any of them really.

Good luck, and please see mine:

viewtopic.php?t=449803