Schaub or Rivers?

[tjdoren]

Matt Schaub vs. JAX, or Phillip Rivers vs. Miami? On a related note, do you think it is smart to keep both of these guys, so I can play the best matchups each week? Or would I be better off trading one of them away to get a better RB (check out my roster)?



My roster:
QB: Rivers, Schaub
RB: L.Johnson, McFadden, Mendenhall, L.White, Buckhalter
WR/TE (we play them as a flex): Fitzgerald, Calvin Johnson, Witten, Cooley, Carlson, Garcon
D: Pats
K: Folk

[spanky123]

Your RBs blow dude. I would start Schaub this week. Good luck.

[splatty129]

Trade Schaub, get a beast RB. Play Rivers vs. Miami definately.. Miami isn't good vs. the passing.

help?
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=449755

[latsprewell20002000]

Yeah you need to do something about your RBs. What did you do? Draft 2 QBs back to back or something? Or not take a RB till the fifth or sixth round? Either way, you should be looking to trade one of those QBs. Trade whoever can get you the better RB. Id play Schaub this week again.

[tjdoren]

My first 8 rounds went like this:

9 Round 1 Fitzgerald, Larry
16 Round 2 Johnson, Calvin
33 Round 3 Rivers, Philip
40 Round 4 Johnson, Larry
57 Round 5 McFadden, Darren
64 Round 6 Witten, Jason
81 Round 7 Schaub, Matt
88 Round 8 Stewart, Jonathan

I was hoping there would be better RB options by Round 4, but I guessed wrong. I traded Stewart for Lendale White this past week. I think if both Rivers and Schaub have good games this week, I'll try to cash in on one of them for a better RB.

[latsprewell20002000]

My first 8 rounds went like this:

9 Round 1 Fitzgerald, Larry
16 Round 2 Johnson, Calvin
33 Round 3 Rivers, Philip
40 Round 4 Johnson, Larry
57 Round 5 McFadden, Darren
64 Round 6 Witten, Jason
81 Round 7 Schaub, Matt
88 Round 8 Stewart, Jonathan

I was hoping there would be better RB options by Round 4, but I guessed wrong. I traded Stewart for Lendale White this past week. I think if both Rivers and Schaub have good games this week, I'll try to cash in on one of them for a better RB.

Okay cool. I could see going the WR/WR if u were at the end of round one like that. One of my friends had tenth pick and went AJ/Fitz back to back. You traded Stewert for L White? You could also trade Calvin or Fitz for maybe a RB and a decent WR to fill in for trading one of them. Thanks for actually coming back and posting your draft!

[FeelDaBrees]

I would start Shaub this week, then trade him for a RB. Gotta keep Rivers. He is more consistent and less injury prone.

Help me please => viewtopic.php?t=449904

[combat Johnny]

Gotta see what you can get for Schaub, but start Rivers vs Miami. help with mine please.. http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=450082