manningham vs s. smith (nyg)

[hers8lax]

I have both and maybe I should keep them both but how would you guys rank them vs each other? Also is it worth starting both?

[Fasteddy]

Hard to answer that Q without knowing all of your WR's. Personally, I like Smith as more of Eli's go to guy on a reg basis. Manningham will have to prove himself over a longer period of time before I change that..... and he might.

please help me back at:
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=449942

[Fasteddy]

Hard to answer that Q without knowing all of your WR's. Personally, I like Smith as more of Eli's go to guy on a reg basis. Manningham will have to prove himself over a longer period of time before I change that..... and he might.

please help me back at:
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=449942

[foxbomb]

I like Smith over Manningham too. History is there and Smith generally gets more looks and catches

viewtopic.php?t=449989

[WWM]

PPR smith
TD-manningham

I grabbed one in one leage and the other in th eother league. I dropped eddie royal for manningham and willie parker for steve smith.