Drop Orton or Garrard? (WHIR)

[toobitter]

12 Team league


McNabb is my starter, so I'm currently starting backups. I picked up Garrard because of my lack of confidence in Orton.

I need to drop one to make room for another injury sub, which one should go?
I definitely prefer Garrard's matchup this week.

[medicinehead]

I think this is almost a toss up. Orton has more upside because of the weapons at his disposal, but has a bigger downside because of his inconsistency. Garrard my not have any HUGE games, but I think he offers you consistent week to week production while McNabb is out. I'm leaning towards dropping Orton.

[Cameron10483]

Drop Orton, keep Garrard. Jax will be throwing a lot due to being not so good, plus Garrard usually sneeks in a cheap 2-3 points cause of his rushing yards

Thanks for the help on mine

[Mark]

Keep Garard, I don't think much of Orton at all!

Please help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=449975&p=3095670#p3095670

Good luck!
Mark

[Humpback]

Neither is a great option, but I'd keep Garrard. Their D has been awful, they should be playing from behind quite a bit.

Plz take a look http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=450173

[GreenEggsAndHam]

I would keep garrard because Orton looks just unimpressive thus far.