Sproles for McGahee? WHIR

[Middle Aged Paunch]

I would do the trade. I agree that Sproles value will go down when LT comes back while McGahee's value remains unchanged due to his role in the offense.

[coltsfan24]

do it...i like mcgahee, especially with the red zone carries

[Team Gooch]

I would take McGahee unless you get points for return yards? Hell, I might even do it anyway. Once LT comes back Sproles, will only be getting 10 or so carries plus a couple of receptions. Thats about the same as McGahee is getting but McGahee's also getting the ones near the goaline and punching them in. Tough call. See how bad he wants Sproles, see if he will throw in another receiver.


Help
viewtopic.php?t=450609

[bostonsoxandy]

It looks like to me that you can't really do that trade just because what if McGahee starts sharing Goal line carries with McClain that would make him not worth OWNING, Sproles is the way to go

[Dawinner127]

Thanks for the help. I would say sit with Sproles. I don't see McGahee continuing with this success for the entire season.

[Foolio]

Hell ya, McGahee OWNS Sproles... Do it for sure!

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=450726

[yanks103000]

definitely do it mcgahee gets goalline

[Skins4Ever]

I would keep Sproles for the time being, I feel that the McGahee train is going to come to a halt.

[Mr. Copernicus]

I like the trade. Even if you view McGahee as being a sell-high, two of your backs -Sproles and Coffee- could be argued to really only have guaranteed value for a few weeks. If you get return points or ppr I guess that's what would make me gun shy about parting with Sproles.